Freelance Writing vs. Writing for a Living: Which One Do You Really Want?

In: Freelance Writing

9 Jun 2009

Side Note: I was quoted in a Web Worker Daily post about Writing Careers. Check it out!

It recently occurred to me that there is a huge difference between freelance writing and writing for a living. It’s actually much like one of those logic questions on the SAT. “If all freelance writers write for a living does that mean all people who write for a living are freelance writers?” Of course it doesn’t.

So what’s the difference, and which one is right for you?

Writing for a Living

If you write for a living, you may very well be a freelance writer. On the other hand, you may work for a newspaper, magazine, textbook company, science lab, or the United Nations. People who want to write for a living simply love creating things with words. They don’t care if they do it from home for a bunch of diverse clients or from an office for one employer.

I’m not saying this is always the case, but people who write for a living may have a harder time making it as a freelance writer. I’ve seen a phenomenon that goes along with this on social media lately. People have found themselves laid off from writing jobs and say, “Hey, I’m available for freelancing. Know about any work?”  They know they want to write, but maybe don’t know that they want all the other trappings that necessarily come along with a freelance writing business. These people just want to shape lovely sentences and get paid for it.

Freelance Writing

Freelance writers don’t just want to write for a living, they want to have a business where they write for a living. They probably don’t get to spend as large a percentage of their time actually writing as those writers who work for an employer, but they also have the freedom to set rates, choose clients, and make all the decisions regarding their careers.

While these people hopefully love writing, they also love things like entrepreneurship and independence.  If they had the choice of writing for an employer and keeping up the freelancing business, they would choose the freelancing business, because they are about more than just writing.

So what about me? I know the right answer here would be to proudly declare, “I’m a freelance writer!” But the truth is, until very recently, I just wanted to write for a living and freelance writing was the most lucrative, interesting and fulfilling way that I could do that. But now, as my business grows, I can honestly say that very few “writing for a living” jobs could make me give up my freelancing business.

How about you? Are you a freelance writer or just someone who wants to write for a living?

For more like this:

What Freelance Writers can Learn from Penguins

What Constitutes a Conflict of Interest for a Freelance Writer?

What Job Posters Really Mean with Freelance Writing Job Ads

Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Print
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon

14 Responses to Freelance Writing vs. Writing for a Living: Which One Do You Really Want?

Avatar

Elaine Grant

June 9th, 2009 at 7:22 am

Good question, Jenn! I’m trying a third way: I used to freelance full time (successfully, for several years) and now I work full time as a reporter for a public radio station. In addition, I’m freelancing on the side. It’s quite a juggle; it’s especially hard finding the time to pitch freelance pieces (as opposed to actually reporting and writing them). I have several good reasons for doing both — one is financial, but the other is that the radio reporting informs my print writing and vice versa. It can be done!

Elaine Grant
http://www.twitter.com/eapplegrant

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 9th, 2009 at 7:33 am

Wow, now that is a writing schedule I can admire. Your life makes me tired just thinking about it!

You saying that the radio reporting informs your print writing reminds of something I was talking about with a friend the other day. She’s job hunting and has a very diverse list of experiences on her resume. She was lamenting the fact that, with unemployment in the States so high, all her dream jobs now require 5 years of very specific experience.

We came to the realization though that the most interesting people are often the ones who have jumped around from job to job or industry to industry (or gig to gig, of course). Maybe they don’t work as Widget Polishers for their entire lives, but they generally do get somewhere interesting and they have diverse life experience that can make all the difference in a job or industry that hires pre-trained Widget Polishers straight out of college.

And of course, you public radio reporters get the best of all worlds – you may be reporting every day, but it’s never on the same thing!

Avatar

Kathryn Lang

June 9th, 2009 at 7:35 am

I am a born entrepreneur (and raising a house of them as well). My first business was when I was seven (and I hired the neighborhood kids to help me run my lemonade stand – I was even features on a Paul Harvey story at the time).

Writing is my passion and freelance writing gives me the ability to write what I want, when I want and where I want. I’ve been encouraged to apply for full time newspaper jobs, but I’m not ready for the structure or the limits.

My husband is just the opposite. He struggles with running his own business because he prefers the structure (and regular paychecks).

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 9th, 2009 at 7:43 am

Ha! Hiring a neighborhood kid to run your lemonade stand is just hilarious. I remember I used to run a Coca Cola stand (naturally, because I’m from Atlanta) at family yard sales when I was a kid. I made a misspelled sign – “Put me through collige” – so I would get more sympathy sales! Where is that marketing savvy now, I wonder?

And I’m glad my point about how some people want or need an employer didn’t come off sounding wrong or condescending to some ears. Some days I’m like your husband and want to be able to simply collect a paycheck and not deal with the stresses of marketing, invoicing and bookkeeping. Most times though, I’m with you and wouldn’t have it any other way.

Also, I really like your blog. It’s similar to what I’m going for in that it has a lot of good tips for newish freelancers. I’m adding it to my Google Reader. Thanks for stopping by and commenting!

Avatar

Vanessa

June 9th, 2009 at 10:18 am

I’m not sure which one I am yet. Since I just started trying to establish a freelance business, I find myself struggling, and gawking at clients who want me to write for them for less than $5 an hour. So at the moment, a steady writing job with a steady pay check sounds pretty sweet. But I’m sticking with freelance for now; we’ll see where it takes me!

Avatar

John Soares

June 9th, 2009 at 12:12 pm

I began my freelance writing career because I wasn’t making good money as a part-time college instructor. I had to become fairly proficient at marketing and sales in order to do well in my writing subfield. But at the time I started, my preference was to a full-time college teacher with summers off for travel.

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 9th, 2009 at 2:59 pm

Vanessa, I was where you are last year and I know that if you keep applying for jobs and don’t undervalue yourself, you will get far. I had a thought for you the other day. Have you thought about applying for staff blogging positions? Check out the Problogger Job Board for a good place to start. http://jobs.problogger.net/

John, It sounds like instead of being all about “writing for a living” you’re all about “teaching for a living.” Is that still the case or are you a “Freelance writer” type these days?

Avatar

Bumbles

June 9th, 2009 at 5:15 pm

I think I’m perfect for staff blogging. I like having some structure/more stability – plus, the marketing world is a scary place for clueless newbies like me.

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 9th, 2009 at 5:17 pm

Bumbles, I think so, too! You know, even if you don’t find a staff blogging job on a job board, you can even try to make your own staff blogging job. Check out some websites for local businesses. Have any of them started a blog and let it languish? Contact them and see if they could use your services!

Avatar

Bumbles

June 9th, 2009 at 11:30 pm

Always full of good ideas Jenn!

Avatar

Kathryn Lang

June 10th, 2009 at 7:41 am

I try to avoid “by the hour” jobs and stick with “by the word or article.” There are days when I can write up to 5 articles in an hour. I would really be undervaluing myself if I was working by the hour. BUT if I can get $8 or $10 for those articles that is a respectable income.

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 10th, 2009 at 1:52 pm

Kathryn, you make a good case for specialization. If you know something well, then it’s just that much easier to write articles about it. And your time should be valued because you took the time to become an expert in that field.

Avatar

Kathryn Lang

June 26th, 2009 at 7:34 am

Hey Jenn – it also should remind me that if I use those times when it is impossible to work (like when the kids are awake) to do research then I can write faster when the opportunity presents itself!

Avatar

Jenn Escalona

June 26th, 2009 at 9:26 am

Good point, Kathryn! Sometimes when I simply don’t feel like writing (and don’t have any pressing deadlines, of course), I use that time to clean out my RSS feed reader, read eBooks I’ve downloaded and generally learn more about the industry. Though I’m not actually writing for billable hours, I’m still learning something and I don’t feel like I’m just wasting the day.

Comment Form

About this blog

Your source for full-time and freelance writing, social media and community management jobs in the Atlanta area and beyond. Subscribe via email or RSS for unadvertised jobs as well as jobs from hidden (and not so hidden) places around the internet. Now with words of wisdom here and there from freelance writing and social media old salt Jennifer Escalona.

Photostream

  • Jenn Escalona: Great resource, Reagan. Thanks for pointing me in the right direction! [...]
  • Reagan: A great source I like for business book summaries is [...]
  • Jenn Escalona: Thanks for the kind compliment, Ashley! Let me know if you have any questions! [...]
  • Ashley: I'm not sure how I missed this post because this blog is definitely in my RSS feed. Better late than [...]
  • Jessica Bailey: Women Issues these days are mostly about women empowerment and equal rights among men.::` [...]

Upcoming Appearances

If you live in the Atlanta area, I would love to meet you. Please see below for a list of events I plan to appear at or attend over the remainder of the year. Stop by and say hi, or better yet, drop me an email and let's coordinate a get together!

December

The Write Room's Playpen (Literary Reading & Music Showcase) - Tuesday, 12/1/09 - Johnnie McCracken's Pub (Marietta, Georgia) - Join us for Festivus!